• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Fellinis Pizzeria – Authentic NY-Style Pizza and Hoagies in Elizabeth, PA

Fellinis Pizzeria in Elizabeth, PA, offers a cozy, small-town vibe with standout New York–style pizza and savory hoagies. Their signature Fellini Rolls impress with a buttery, crunchy crust and rich filling, making them a must-try. Customers praise the fresh, flavorful sauce and perfectly cooked pizzas, often delivered hot and on time, even for local events. The hoagies boast excellent bread and generous fillings, consistently satisfying repeat visitors. Though modest inside, the friendly service and generous portions create a welcoming atmosphere. Fellinis balances quality and comfort, making it a go-to spot for both dine-in and takeout in this community.

Fellinis Pizzeria at a glance

  • Address 107 N 2nd Ave, Elizabeth, PA 15037, United States
  • Phone +1 412-405-8699
  • Restaurant type Italian restaurant .
  • Popular for Lunch , Dinner , Solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Fellinis Pizzeria: Reviews & Ratings

Clara Chapman
5

I have to admit. I didn’t really think this place would be very good. Other dinner plans fell through and I stopped in because we were already parked and we had plans to go to fire whistle for their Tuesday night piano comedy show. Hesitantly I ordered the Fellini Rolls and some fried Mac and cheese. They deliver to the fire whistle next door so we didn’t have to wait around. Which is really nice. When we got our food I was blown away. The rolls are SO GOOD! They’re so buttery! Soft but with a nice crunchy outside! There was plenty of filling in it, unlike some other rolls which are mostly bread. I shouldn’t have been so quick to dismiss this really good place. If I’m ever back in town again I’m picking up another chicken bacon cheddar roll.

Todd Knisley
4

From the outside this looks like a very small, small-town pizza shop. It is relatively small inside with most orders seemingly being for pickup, but there are several tables inside for eating in. We ordered two "hoagies" (subs) and a small pizza. The bread used for the subs is great. Both subs were very good as was the thin NY-style pizza. We ordered a small pizza and what came out was very much more a "medium" in size and what some post-COVID places are calling "large". Street-side parking is easy and plentiful. The Steelers were being televised inside and everything worked out to be a good experience. I am usually in town once a year and will be sure to stop back in next year.

Meghan Kibe
5

We have never had a bad hoagie here. We ordered pizza for the first time for the family with their Valentine’s Day heart pizza. And even with delivery it came hot. Definitely one of the best pizza places in Elizabeth.

Bobbie K
5

Saw a Facebook post for this place and had me very intrigued. I decided to stop by today and grab a pizza. I was not disappointed. The service was friendly . Food was quick hot and looked amazing. Decided to eat in because I didn't want to wait 30 more minutes to eat. The sauce was phenomenal. Pizza was absolutely delicious. The cheese bread sticks were good. But wasn't really a fan. I shared them with the teenage boys who came in after me. They devoured them so i guess they were good. I would definitely eat here again.

Dalton Young
5

Food was good cooked very nicely, a little pricey but its okay, staff were polite to me and friends the only thing was we waited 45 mins for fries but its okay they came out hot that's all that matters. Sauces tasted yummy I highly suggest

Location

  • Fellinis Pizzeria
    Fellinis Pizzeria
    107 N 2nd Ave, Elizabeth, PA 15037, United States Hotline: +1 412-405-8699

Fellinis Pizzeria sits quietly in Elizabeth, PA, offering more than its modest storefront suggests. This spot might appear like your typical small-town pizza shop, but the food tells a richer story. From my first bite of the Fellini Rolls, it became clear this place knows how to craft simple comfort food with care and flavor. The rolls bring a perfect balance of a buttery, soft interior and a satisfyingly crunchy outside, packed with generous fillings that defy the usual bread-heavy norm.

The menu extends beyond pizza, with sub sandwiches that truly shine thanks to fresh, high-quality bread and balanced fillings. Customers often praise their hoagies, which consistently deliver robust flavors and freshness. Their thin New York-style pizza is another highlight—deceptively sized larger than expected and featuring a sauce that’s been described as phenomenal, adding a bold, tangy depth that complements the melty cheese and crisp crust. The Valentine’s Day heart pizza, a charming seasonal touch, emphasizes their creativity and attention to maintaining heat and texture even for delivery.

Service here leans friendly and attentive, with staff willing to accommodate delivery next door so diners can enjoy a show or keep moving without the wait. While wait times for some sides like fries can stretch, the quality remains intact, arriving hot and fresh. The cheese bread sticks may divide opinion, but even those not enamored have noted they satisfy younger tastes. Parking is easy and plentiful, making this a convenient stop for locals and visitors alike.

Overall, Fellinis Pizzeria provides more than just a quick meal. It offers the kind of genuine, hearty fare that carries flavor in every bite and warmth in every visit. Whether you’re craving buttery rolled appetizers, crispy thin-crust pizza, or a classic hoagie done right, Fellinis delivers a welcoming experience worth returning to.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Wheelchair-accessible seating
  • Service options
    • No-contact delivery
    • Delivery
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards
    • Credit cards